Regulations, ordinances, or rules enacted by a private corporation for its own government A by law is a rule or law of a corporation, for its government, and is a legislative act, and the solemnities and sanction required by the charter must be observed. A resolution is not necessarily a by law though a by law may be in the form of a resolution Peck v. Elliott, 79 Fed. 10, 24 O. C. A. 425, 38 L. R. A. 616; Mining Oo. v. King, 94 Wis. 439, 69 N. W. 181, 36 L. R. A. 51; Bagley v. Oil Co., 201 Pa. 78, 50 Atl. 760, 56 L. R. A. 184; Dairy Ass’n v. Webb, 40 App. Div. 49, 57 N. Y. Supp. 572. “That the reasonableness of a by law of a corporation is a question of law, and not of fact, has always been the established rule; but in the case of State v. Overton, 24 N. J. Law, 435, 61 Am. Dec. 671, a distinction was taken in this respect between a by law and a regulation, the validity of the former being a judicial question, while the latter was regarded as a matter xn pais. But although, in one of the opinions read in the case referred to, the view was clearly expressed that the reasonableness of a corporate regulation was properly for the consideration of the jury, and not of the court, yet it was nevertheless stated that the point was not involved in the controversy then to be decided. There is no doubt that the rule thus intimated is in opposition to recent American authorities. Nor have I been able to find in the English books any such distinction as that above stated between a by law and a regulation of a corporation.” Compton v. Van Vol kenburgh, 34 N. J. Law, 135. or town. But of late the tendency is to employ the word “ordinauce” exclusively for this class of enactments, reserving “by law” for the rules adopted by private corporations.